Search  About Salon  Table Talk  Newsletters: subscribe/unsubscribe  Advertise in Salon  Investor Relations

 
 

Salon.com

[Arts & Entertainment][ Books ][ Comics ][ Life ][ News ][ People ][ Politics ][ Sex ][ Technology ][ Audio ]

Article Finder
Arts & Entertainment


 


ent


Box of Stones
Is Oliver Stone a misunderstood cinematic genius or just a deluded, self-absorbed hack? A new 10-DVD box set promises some answers.

- - - - - - - - - - - -
By Bruce Kluger

Feb. 26, 2001 Before it vanished from the Internet earlier this month (as popular Web sites are prone to do), one particular Oliver Stone home page featured a photo of the controversial filmmaker beneath a large red headline that read: "Oliver Stone: Writer, Director, Thinker."

This type of hyperbolic puffery is not uncommon on the Internet, especially among diehard movie fans who delight in devoting enormous chunks of time and bandwidth to deifying their cultural idols. What distinguished this gush-fest from the others, however, was that the site -- OliverStone.com -- was the director's own Internet boutique, a Web-chapel of self-devotion where Stone offered commentary on his movies and the film industry in general, and also dumped samples of his writing, merchandise and, as always, a blizzard of opinions on everything from the Vietnam War and the JFK assassination to being misunderstood by the media and the true nature of evil.




Print story


E-mail story


That's a lot of self-promotion, even for man doing triple-duty as a writer, director and thinker.

Then again, it is this very Ptolemaic view of the world -- in which the universe revolves around him and his movies -- that makes Oliver Stone one of the more compelling, analyzed and, to some, important directors in American cinema. Because he chooses to make films about real-life subjects and events -- often to the chagrin of historians and scholars who like to challenge his accuracy -- it is a given that when a Stone movie opens, it will have an agenda that goes beyond simply chasing the Gibsons and Grinches to the top of the weekend grosses heap.

True, in the case of Stone's work, those agendas can be maddening and misguided -- witness the general public outrage over his gratuitous 1994 gore orgy, "Natural Born Killers." But in Hollywood's ongoing battle between the usually profitless think picture and the enormously successful dumb-and-dumber formula, Stone has staked out a comfortable middle ground with a body of work that attempts to educate -- sometimes enlightening moviegoers, other times haranguing them -- even as it entertains.

"Oliver Stone's place in motion pictures is yet to be decided," writes Michael Singer in "Etched in Stone: The Films of Oliver Stone," "but this much is sure: He is in love with the primal, even terrifying, power of film, and he's been completely unafraid to harness that energy and unleash it with explosive impact on cinematic, social and political landscapes."

But as more filmmakers begin painting on nonfiction canvases both large and small (from "Erin Brockovich" to "Thirteen Days"), Stone may find his role as Hollywood's leading moviemaker-historian and unrepentant boat-rocker eliciting more yawns than gasps.

Scanning the 10 titles in the new Warner Bros. DVD box set of Oliver Stone movies made between the years 1987 and 1999, you can't help but note that Stone's trajectory over the last 15 years has been a curious one. His popularity at the box office continues on an even keel even as his stock in trade -- overturning historical and cultural rocks to reveal the creepy crawling universes beneath our national institutions -- loses its jolt.

For example, while many critics yowled at the artistic and factual liberties Stone took in decrying the Warren Commission Report in his 1991 Kennedy assassination exposé, "JFK," most simply shrugged eight years later when he pulled back the curtain on similar intrigue and corruption in the locker rooms and front offices of professional football ("Any Given Sunday"). Either America has gotten less interesting in the past decade, this phenomenon suggests, or it is no longer rattled by its own lapses. (The Clinton administration, all by itself, dispels the former notion while handily supporting the latter.)

To be fair, Stone is not entirely responsible for the relative ennui his recent films seem to provoke. After all, he is now peddling to an entertainment culture that finds "The NewsHour With Jim Lehrer" slotted opposite "Extra!" and "Access Hollywood," and prime time dominated by programs like "Temptation Island" and "Survivor" -- freak shows that seek to normalize the very kind of human ugliness that an Oliver Stone movie normally takes two or three hours to uncover.

Still, one has to wonder if Stone's varying degrees of success and failure over the years have been a result of his selection of material, the temperament of the country at the time of the films' releases, or perhaps a little of both.

Strangely, the DVD box set does not include the movie that put Oliver Stone on the map. By the time he wrote and directed "Platoon" (1986), Stone had labored as a screenwriter in the film industry for more than a decade, with credits on films like "Midnight Express" (for which he won an Oscar), "Conan the Barbarian" (1982), "Scarface" (1983) and "Year of the Dragon" (1985). But it was his unapologetic, first-person portrait of a young G.I. in Vietnam -- based on his own tours of duty there between 1965 and 1968 -- that captured the true brutality of the war. The film won him a new following as well as a tentative slot in the dependable rotation of auterists' favorite working American directors of that time -- Steven Spielberg, Martin Scorsese, Francis Ford Coppola, Robert Altman and Woody Allen.

The "Stone Collection" does, however, include "Born on the Fourth of July" and "Heaven and Earth," the second and third installments of the director's Vietnam trilogy, both of which still resonate. (Both DVDs, like all of the films in the box set except for "U-Turn" and "Talk Radio," feature full-length director commentaries. "JFK," "Nixon," "The Doors" and "Any Given Sunday" also include bonus discs filled with extras like deleted scenes, making-of documentaries and, in the case of "Sunday," screen tests and a gag reel.)

"Born on the Fourth of July" (1989) was not the first film to explore the emotional and physical trauma suffered by soldiers returning stateside from Vietnam; "Coming Home" and "The Deer Hunter" had both examined the subject with candor and sensitivity. But what Stone's movie offered that the others didn't was a real-life hero, Ron Kovic, whose passionate memoir served as the basis for the film. Kovic's character (portrayed with painful honesty by Tom Cruise, much of the time confined to a wheelchair) remains a documented casualty of the war, not merely a collage or interpretation (à la Charlie Sheen's character in "Platoon") that critics could brush aside as another example of Stone over-reaching.

Similarly, "Heaven and Earth" (1993) draws from the autobiography of Le Ly Hayslip, a Vietnamese woman whose life story charts a cyclical course from the serene, pre-war countryside of her homeland to the mayhem of the Viet Cong insurgence to her enlightening return to the tenets of Buddhism in the aftermath of the war. Overlooked and underappreciated by moviegoers and critics, "Heaven and Earth" remains a beautiful and touching film and, on a personal level, one of Stone's favorites.

. Next page | The critics and the public turn on Stone
1, 2





 



Don't get sunburned!Cover up with a Salon T-shirt this summer.




Extra goodies and great services in
Salon Plus

____
 
   
 
____
 



 
 
____
 
  Current Stories
  • Peter Jackson's alien-apartheid apocalypse Will the dark political allegory (and ass-kickin' robots) of "District 9" redeem a crap-movie summer?
    Andrew O'Hehir
  • Thank God it's "Humpday" Lynn Shelton's breakthrough bromance comedy is funny, sharp and true -- with no preachy sexual politics
    Andrew O'Hehir
  • "I Love You, Beth Cooper" This summer teen romance hopes to sidestep cliche with doses of sweetness, intelligence -- and Hayden Panettiere
    By Stephanie Zacharek
  • Why "Brüno" is bad for the gays Sacha Baron Cohen's character could have been a bold stab at homophobia. Instead it's a mincing minstrel show
    By David Rakoff
  •  

    shim shim shim shim shim shim shim
    shim
    shim

    Now playing: Read all the recent movie reviews by Salon's critics

    shim
    shim


     


    Salon  Search  About Salon  Table Talk  Newsletters: subscribe/unsubscribe  Advertise in Salon  Investor Relations


    Arts & Entertainment | Books | Comics | Life | News | People
    Politics | Sex | Tech & Business and The Free Software Project | Audio
    Letters | Columnists | Salon Plus | Salon Shop


    Reproduction of material from any Salon pages without written permission is strictly prohibited
    Copyright 2005 Salon.com


    Salon, 22 4th Street, 16th Floor, San Francisco, CA 94103
    Telephone 415 645-9200 | Fax 415 645-9204
    E-mail | Salon.com Privacy Policy