Search  About Salon  Table Talk  Newsletters  Advertise in Salon  Investor Relations

Salon.com

Multimedia
[Arts & Entertainment][ Books ][ Business ][ Comics ][ Health & Body ][ Mothers Who Think ][ News ][ People ][ Politics ][ Sex ][ Technology ]

Article Finder
Business


 


napster death match


Music
- - - - - - - - - - - -


Napster death match, Round 3
Fending off a life-threatening court injunction, file-swapping phenom Napster insists it has done nothing wrong.

- - - - - - - - - - - -
By Eric Boehlert

July 7, 2000 | So much for David vs. Goliath.

Any lingering notion that the battle between Napster and the Recording Industry Association of America is the legal equivalent of a powerless Internet start-up fighting off a monstrous industry tool was dashed on Monday when Napster filed its rebuttal in a San Francisco U.S. District Court.




Print story


E-mail story


Backflip This Story  Backflip this article to find it again


Napster, which was rebutting a RIAA request that the music-swapping company be shut down for rampant copyright infringements, has proved, among other things, that the once-tiny concern has become Big Business.

Napster recently secured $13 million in funding from one of Silicon Valley's largest venture capital firms. Meanwhile, its legal brief's cover page boasted three law firms on two coasts, led by attorney David Boies, who may be the most sought after white-shoe lawyer in the nation. (Boies is coming off the successful prosecution of the Justice Department's antitrust case against Microsoft.)

Thirty-four pages later, the Napster lawyers note that if Judge Marilyn Patel shuts down the company, a bond will have to be posted "to cover all potential injury pending trial" -- which means that if Napster wins on appeal, it can recover money lost during the injunction downtime.

The amount of the bond? First consider recent press reports that Napster, despite zero revenue and profits, is worth between $60 million and $80 million. Instead, company lawyers argue, "when comparing Napster to Internet companies with comparable numbers of active users, Napster's market value is between $1.5 and $2 billion." That's right, billion.

The revelation is just one of many intriguing passages in the no-stone-unturned filing, which argues strenuously that Napster's file swapping is perfectly legal.

The skirmish centers around RIAA's June 12 request that Napster be shut down on the grounds that the company is guilty of "contributory and vicarious copyright infringement." In other words, Napster knowingly allows -- and abets -- 10 million users to swap unauthorized MP3 music files. The argument has been going on for some time: Napster tried to get an earlier RIAA lawsuit dismissed by suggesting that its actions were covered by the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (which provides immunity, or "safe harbor," for online portals that merely connect individual users). Judge Patel essentially denied that request. Patel will hold a hearing on July 26 to decide the injunction issue.

Taking its cue from the judge, Napster in its latest brief basically ditches the DMCA defense (although there is a halfhearted attempt to revive it), and instead focuses on the broader question of whether Napster even needs immunity from copyright infringements. Boies and company insist it does not.

. Next page | So is it legal?
1, 2, 3




Illustration by Jennifer Ormerod/Salon.com


 

Need a gift? Visit Salon Shop for inspiration.




More great offers in
Salon Plus

____
 
   
 
____
 
  Current Stories
  • I went to Brand Camp and all I got was this dumb snack-food epiphany We have seen the reality TV of the future, and it is 20 hipsters spending a loft weekend thinking about packaged goods.
    By Ruth Shalit
  • Is it safe? When violence flares and travelers beware, who profits from the scare?
    By Don George
  • Bull market for market bull The villain in "M:i-2" demands a new popular-culture perquisite: Stock options.
    By Steve Bodow
  •  

    Sign up to receive free e-mail updates from Salon -- now in 17 different varieties!



    Salon  Search  About Salon  Table Talk  Newsletters  Advertise in Salon  Investor Relations


    Arts & Entertainment | Books | Business | Comics | Health | Mothers Who Think | News
    People | Politics | Sex | Technology and The Free Software Project
    Letters | Columnists | Salon Plus | Salon Shop


    Reproduction of material from any Salon pages without written permission is strictly prohibited
    Copyright © 2000 Salon.com
    Salon, 22 4th Street, 16th Floor, San Francisco, CA 94103
    Telephone 415 645-9200 | Fax 415 645-9204
    E-mail | Salon.com Privacy Policy