Search  About Salon  Table Talk  Newsletters  Advertise in Salon  Investor Relations

Salon.com


[Arts & Entertainment][ Books ][ Business ][ Comics ][ Health & Body ][ Mothers Who Think ][ News ][ People ][ Politics ][ Sex ][ Technology ]

Article Finder
Books


 


Harry Potter fans detect devilish discrepancy
Did J.K. Rowling goof or has she another trick up her sleeve?

Editor's note: The following contains details concerning the ending of "Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire."

- - - - - - - - - - - -
By Garth Johnston

July 24, 2000 | In the past two weeks, everyone from Harold Bloom to Jay Leno has had a chance to talk about J.K. Rowling's new book, the 752-page "Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire." But while discussion has ranged from the literary merits of the book to how Scholastic was able to pull off an astounding 3.8 million-copy print run in nearly absolute secrecy, a handful of fans have noticed what may or may not be a slip on Rowling's part.

One of the most highly praised features of the Harry Potter series has been the detailed history of the world that surrounds its orphaned hero. But during the climactic confrontation at the conclusion of "Goblet of Fire," the very order in which Harry's parents were murdered by the evil Lord Voldemort seems to be brought into question. During the high-stakes battle between Voldemort and Harry, as a result of complications in the wands that they both use, Harry forces the ghosts of all those whom Voldemort has killed with his wand to eject themselves momentarily into the living world.




Print story


E-mail story


Backflip This Story  Backflip this story to find it again


The book specifically notes that they emerge in the reverse of the order in which they were killed. First comes Cedric, the popular Hogwarts Quidditch player, who was most recently killed by Voldemort, then the groundskeeper of the Riddle Estate (whose murder was excerpted in Newsweek), then "missing" witch Bertha Jorkins, followed by Harry's parents. Here is where fans of the series are scratching their heads. Margo Alexandra, a student at the University of Chicago, was one of many who noticed that "Harry's parents come out in the wrong order."

Rowling's previous books have indicated that Harry's father died first, in an attempt to protect his wife and child, and that only after his failure was Harry's mother killed, while placing a spell over her son that granted him some form of protection from Voldemort. But when the ghosts start coming out of Voldemort's wand, Harry's dad comes out first, with his mother close behind.

Was the discrepancy a mistake? A slip-up? Or something more? What other plot twists might J.K. Rowling have up her sleeve? The only thing her fans can do is sit back, maybe reread the first book or two, gripe about the upcoming movie and wait for "Harry Potter V."


salon.com | July 24, 2000

- - - - - - - - - - - -

About the writer
Garth Johnston is a student at Stuyvesant High School in New York.

Sound Off
Send us a Letter to the Editor

Related stories
Read more Salon stories about Harry Potter.


Table Talk

Witches and pagans and broomsticks, oh my Are you offended by the Harry Potter backlash?

Salon.com >> Books
 




 



Don't get sunburned!  Cover up with a Salon T-shirt this summer.




More great offers in
Salon Plus

____
 
   
 
____
 
  Current Stories
  • IKEA is as bad as Wal-Mart Everyone loves a bargain, but a new book illuminates the dangers of cheap stuff
    By Stephanie Zacharek
  • History is bunk after all Much of what we're taught has been twisted to suit someone's needs
    By Laura Miller
  • How blogs changed everything As old media struggles for relevance, the once-maligned blogosphere proves it's as transformative as the telephone
    By Scott Rosenberg
  • The un-American way of life A controversial new history of Communism suggests that most everything we think we know about it is wrong
    By Andrew O'Hehir
  •  

    Maya Angelou reads from "The Heart of a Woman"



    Salon  Search  About Salon  Table Talk  Newsletters  Advertise in Salon  Investor Relations


    Arts & Entertainment | Books | Business | Comics | Health | Mothers Who Think | News
    People | Politics | Sex | Technology and The Free Software Project
    Letters | Columnists | Salon Plus | Salon Shop


    Reproduction of material from any Salon pages without written permission is strictly prohibited
    Copyright © 2000 Salon.com
    Salon, 22 4th Street, 16th Floor, San Francisco, CA 94103
    Telephone 415 645-9200 | Fax 415 645-9204
    E-mail | Salon.com Privacy Policy