Search  About Salon  Table Talk  Newsletters  Advertise in Salon  Investor Relations

 
 

Salon.com

[Arts & Entertainment][ Books ][ Comics ][ Mothers Who Think ][ News ][ People ][ Politics ][ Sex ][ Technology ][ Audio ]

Article Finder



 


books


Decoding the genome
Six new books tackle human biology's Holy Grail, but each fights its own crusade.

- - - - - - - - - - - -
By Ralph Brave

Jan. 9, 2001 | The text of the human genome -- those 3 billion-plus bits of DNA that contain the basic instructions for constructing and operating a human body -- is now in the hands of editors at Science magazine and is due to be published early this year. An astonishing scientific accomplishment, all acknowledge. But equally astonishing is how little of that text we are currently capable of reading. It's as if we had a list of all words in the English language but lacked a dictionary to tell us what they mean.

No one knows how quickly we will decipher this "code of codes," the Holy Grail of human biology. Both the biotech industry, which has a considerable investment at stake, and scientists, who seek to alleviate suffering, to secure a place in history and to make their own molecular millions, want to move rapidly. Yet, facing a genome that contains thousands of genes, coding for a million or more different proteins (the biochemical powerhouses that do much of the work in making a human and guiding its functioning), they have a long road ahead. And we know even less about the proteome (the entire array of human proteins) than we do about the genome. That's why J. Craig Venter, president of the Celera Corp., who delivered the genome text to Science, told a science writer earlier this year, "We don't know shit about biology."



Cracking the Genome: Inside the Race to Unlock Human DNA

By Kevin Davies

The Free Press
288 pages
Nonfiction

Buy it


Genome: The Autobiography of a Species in 23 Chapters

By Matt Ridley

HarperCollins
352 pages
Nonfiction

Buy it


The Triple Helix: Gene, Organism and Environment

By Richard Lewontin

Harvard Univ. Press
192 pages
Nonfiction

Buy it


A Darwinian Left: Politics, Evolution and Cooperation

By Peter Singer

Yale Univ. Press
64 pages
Nonfiction

Buy it


Engineering the Human Germline: An Exploration of the Science and Ethics of Altering the Genes We Pass to Our Children

Edited by Gregory Stock and John Campbell

Oxford Univ. Press
208 pages
Nonfiction

Buy it


The Second Creation: Dolly and the Age of Biological Control

By Ian Wilmut Keith Campbell and Colin Tudge

Farrar, Straus and Giroux
320 pages
Nonfiction

Buy it



Print story


E-mail story


View Salon privately with SafeWeb


This strange moment, in which we hold the genetic keys but have no idea which doors they open, has given rise to a peculiar literature. Writers naturally want to tout the very real importance of their subject, but when it comes to what it all signifies, they don't have much solid data to work with. The result is a series of books that walk a tightrope between the minutiae of biochemical structures and mechanics, with their attendant technical vocabularies, and the most open-ended speculation about how a new era of genomics will affect humanity.

It's hard to single out any one of these books for recommendation. The authors have varying strengths and weaknesses in making the science accessible, and when it comes to sketching the outer reaches of scientific possibility, the human genome currently functions as a kind of Rorschach inkblot. Each author's beliefs and politics determine much of what he or she thinks the genome can tell us. And there are some big questions at stake here: When we fully understand the genome, will we know ourselves? Will this knowledge require a revolution in our understanding of what it means to be human? If so, do we even possess the cognitive capacity to grasp it? What limits can and should be drawn around what we do with that knowledge? And who shall decide?

The most recent addition to the shelf of books on the Human Genome Project (and the first account to include the completion of the project), "Cracking the Genome: Inside the Race to Unlock Human DNA" by Kevin Davies, is also the most disappointing. Davies is a clear and competent writer, and his book doesn't contain any inaccuracies or gross distortions -- all of which are great virtues in science writing. But for a book with the word "Inside" in its title, "Cracking the Genome" contains very little inside to speak of. Instead, it's an entirely derivative artifact, cobbled together from secondary sources, with only a few original interviews, none of them providing anything remotely resembling behind-the-scenes revelations.

Even a casual but consistent reader of the coverage of the genome project by the New York Times' Nicholas Wade or the Washington Post's Rick Weiss would spend $25 on Davies' book to learn nothing new. The author tacitly, if not guiltily, admits as much in his acknowledgments when he thanks Wade, "whose superb coverage of all aspects of this story has been invaluable." (We can only hope Davies has enough integrity to also share with Wade whatever fee he received to write the book.)

An accomplished science editor and writer with a Ph.D. in genetics from Oxford, Davies says his goal was "to capture the excitement, intrigue, mystery and majesty of the quest for biology's holy grail" and not to pen "the definitive record" of the genome project. In that, alas, he also fails. He breaks up his narrative of "the race" to sequence the genome with sections and even entire chapters that address subjects that, while often interesting, are only indirectly related to the project. Any approximation of excitement or mystery he generates is quickly dissipated by the padding.

 

. Next page | Praised genome book with a libertarian bias
1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6





 



Don't get sunburned!  Cover up with a Salon T-shirt this summer.




Extra goodies and great services in
Salon Plus

____
 




 
 
____
 
   
 
____
 
  Current Stories
  • History is bunk after all Much of what we're taught has been twisted to suit someone's needs
    By Laura Miller
  • How blogs changed everything As old media struggles for relevance, the once-maligned blogosphere proves it's as transformative as the telephone
    By Scott Rosenberg
  • The un-American way of life A controversial new history of Communism suggests that most everything we think we know about it is wrong
    By Andrew O'Hehir
  • Gay men go to hell "God Says No" author James Hannaham talks about religious repression, life in the closet -- and sex in the bathroom
    By Sarah Hepola
  •  

    shim shim shim shim shim shim shim
    shim
    shim

    Maya Angelou reads from "The Heart of a Woman"

    shim
    shim



    Salon  Search  About Salon  Table Talk  Newsletters  Advertise in Salon  Investor Relations


    Arts & Entertainment | Books | Comics | Mothers Who Think | News
    People | Politics | Sex | Tech & Business and The Free Software Project
    Letters | Columnists | Salon Plus | Salon Shop


    Reproduction of material from any Salon pages without written permission is strictly prohibited
    Copyright 2005 Salon.com


    Salon, 22 4th Street, 16th Floor, San Francisco, CA 94103
    Telephone 415 645-9200 | Fax 415 645-9204
    E-mail | Salon.com Privacy Policy